Steel Train - Steel Train (2010)

Artist/Album: Steel Train – Steel Train

Totally Subjective Number Rating: 7/10

Recommended if you like: The Format, Tegan and Sara, bands like that.

Released By: Terrible Thrills (the band’s own label)

Favorite Tracks: “Bullet,” “You and I Undercover,” “Children of the 90's,” “Soldier in the Army”

Steel Train’s third album begins with what might be my new favorite song of theirs, “Bullet.” It’s a song that alternates between the two distinct strains of their sound. It has that U2 arena momentum that they excelled at on songs like “Kill Monsters in the Rain” off their 2007 album Trampoline. The chorus is a bouncy, sing-along passage lead by acoustic guitar strumming. These styles are almost two extremes, the first sounding huge and the second warm and intimate. Steel Train do both very well and it makes for a good pop song, but they don’t really do that throughout. Sometimes they seem to stray towards an eccentricity I associate with indie rock, by which I mean a sort of franticness that comes at the expense of catchiness. In a number of places the hooks just don’t go where you might want them to go, and I applaud Steel Train for not being overly predictable, but wish more of their songs would be as catchy as “Bullet” or “Soldier in the Army.” I couldn’t warm up to all of these songs, which is a shame because the songs I could warm up to I absolutely love. This is an album of peaks and valleys—really high peaks and valleys that are just low enough for you to really miss the peaks. Steel Train brings a fun energy to songs that are about serious things and they value musicianship and that makes for an album on which nothing is hard to listen to and it’s a hard album for all but the most hardcore indie-heads to hate. If you liked their past work, especially their last album, this might work for you. Also, if you like pop music with synths, with a fun spirit, that likes the rock at times, and aren’t afraid of a few left-field songwriting choices, Steel Train might be worth your time.